To Matthew Quick's credit, his debut novel has a pretty great premise and runs with it. The story is a deconstruction of the romantic comedy, choosing more to explore what these different forms of addiction bring to our lives. Without ever feeling too weighty, he explores how the cross-section of relationships, family, and sports can impact our emotional health, making us see things that may not always be rational, but give some relief to our stressful lives. "The Silver Linings Playbook" never plays like a conventional novel, and yet still delivers those feel-good moments that make this a fun and breezy read. If you don't like sports, it'll subliminally make you understand why it's sometimes essential to scream "E!A!G!L!E!S! Eagles!" with a group of strangers. This is about understanding ourselves in a contemporary setting and does so with a fluency that is admirable.
When the story introduces narrator Pat Peoples, there is this sense that something is wrong. Complicated concepts are dumbed down. He's talking to a therapist. Most importantly, he envisions his whole life as a movie, believing that his life will have this perfect happy ending. He has a regimented schedule, constantly lifting weights and watching Eagles NFL games with his father, believing that their rituals somehow inform their success rate. It's the type of story where Pat talks about his therapist as if they're best friends. He seems like this young and naive man, wanting a world that doesn't fully exist, and the whole story from there is about him returning to reality.
Of course, the issue is that his happy ending involves getting back with his ex-wife. As the audience will discover by the end, they're separated for emotional reasons. Pat wants to better himself for her, believing that she is his "silver lining." Since she is a high school English teacher, he reads books like "The Bell Jar" and "The Great Gatsby," eagerly trying to find deeper meaning in what will make Nikki see him as this well-educated man. With each read comes major spoilers for classic literature, but they also reveal something that everyone faces with media: the best can secretly give us life lessons. Quick's approach may seem like cheap references at first, but if you apply it to his emotional growth, it's quite effective at conveying how Pat sees the world.
This is a story about mental health as it relates to all facets of life. Pat finds it through a relationship with Tiffany, who also seems emotionally damaged but comes to love Pat for who he is. Together they find ways to become more than an incompatible couple. Sure she has to compete with football, but there is this sense that everything is presenting new life lessons for Pat to grow as a person. Tiffany embodies something closer to the romantic comedy skewering, where neither feels like a conventionally good person, but you still believe that there's something to be had with them being together. The third act (which wasn't featured in the 2012 adaptation) finds the road becoming more complicated when a series of letters find Pat accepting his divorce in ways that have a devious undertone, even if there's a better sense of closure that comes from it.
Beyond all of this, the thing that makes Quick's novel worthy of consideration is how it treats sports. While there's plenty to love about watching the game, Quick is more interested in the way that it brings people together, making them feel this fulfillment with a warped family perspective. To read about Pat's tailgating parties is to finally understand why this behavior is something akin to a cult, and it subliminally ties to other emotional lessons we've learned up to this point. It even has the place of Pat's greatest growth as a character, where one accidental fight leads him to recognize the levity of his actions. Without moments like this, we can't hope to contextualize Pat as recovering. He's trying to be a better person, and having a support group that loves sports (notably the memorable Asian Invasion) shows how everyone can make Pat's life better.
As mentioned, this is a breezy novel that excels above its gimmick. While it suggests that Pat's story is like a movie, it never feels like one. Instead it's a confessional, may be reminiscent of a diary. The frays of characters just outside of his view begin to make sense as to how they inform his previous actions. Everyone around Pat has some emotional baggage being carried, and this clarity makes us understand Pat on a more personal level, as well as how some people could do with the therapy used to fix Pat. This is an acceptance that everyone is messed up, but that we're all ultimately capable of love. It's a romantic comedy that puts self-care first, and it's refreshing and ultimately endearing. Much like Quick's name, there's never a point where it feels like a burden to complete. Even then the average page is so full of insight and detail that makes it a rewarding experience.
"The Silver Linings Playbook" is a solid book that manages to explore a lot of complicated subjects in a contemporary way that creates a better snapshot than any psychology book. By reflecting on mental health in sports, it shows a side that hasn't often been explored and makes it endearing. It's a compassionate, heartfelt story worthy of being seen of many things. It's a romantic comedy, but it's also a character study that captures masculinity in ways that aren't often seen. Jocks have feelings too, and rarely have they felt as dynamic as Pat Peoples. He may have not gotten the silver lining that he wanted, but the ending creates something even better and more rewarding. It's the type that brings everything together in a beautiful dovetailing. We all want to get to the silver lining, and like this book it feels rewarding to finally see it.
No comments:
Post a Comment